samurai vs knight samurai and knights were different but the similarities were greater because of their rankings, training, armor, fighting technique, code of honor, and death viewpoint the japanese called their warriors samurai , and the europeans called their warriors knights. To whom did the samurai and knights owe loyalty to the daimyos and the artisans the shogun and the pope the merchants and the lords the daimyos and the lesser lords 3 mins. The knights of circa 1100 and the samurai of circa 1200 were roughly evenly matched in equipment but the same comparative warriors during the 1400's for instance, were quite dissimilar.
For a knight to slay a surrendered foe was the height of dishonour, while a samurai deemed surrender itself to be dishonourable a knight's life belonged to god, so to take one's own life was a sin for the samurai, ritual suicide (known as 'seppuku') was not only allowed, it was required in certain situations. The classic question, knight versus samurai, who would win in a fight. By comparison, knights were much more brutal than their samurai counterparts, as europe at the time had a lot more battles, which allowed most knights to have considerable combat experience. A samurai is a person either born into or raised to the warrior class and adopts a warriors way of life, serving a particular fief lord either in administrative or military capability.
Knights were usually christian, while samurai followed buddhism, daoism, and confucianism one group of warriors were european, while the other was japanese both wore different types of protective gear. The samurai and the knight had his origins in military and economic need his role was as a warrior, and like the samurai in some cases he was little more than a thug rewarded for his viciousness but if a knight was to succeed, he had to take his role in the military seriously. Secondly samurai's and knights swore on an oath to their lords samurais and knights had to be very loyal to be a good samurai or knight also to be a good samurai or knight you would have to have good military service. A comparative video based on accademic research here i shall examine the european knight and compare his weapons armours and fighting style with that of the japanese samurai. The the most important class of citizens was the warrior class they were called samurai in japan and knights europe the warriors served local lords and were bound by code of ethics knights code of ethics was chivalry while the samurai was the bushido.
The samurai's bushido and the european knights chivalry were both codes of honor which consisted of fighting for their earthly lord, but when it came down to committing ritual suicide for their god only samurais were up for the challenge setting them aside from the knights. The samurai had horns or wings on their helmets and the knights often had feathers comming out of their armour differences now they lived on different sides of the world, and had never met so there is alot of differences. Both samurai and knight start their training from childhood if a samurai dad was a samurai he also has to become a samurai if a knight dad was a knight, it was optional for him to become a knight.
The samurai of feudal japan and the medieval knights of europe had underlying similarities and differences the comparison between these two elite, aristocratic warriors can be shown through their honour, military technology, and challenges a typical warrior had to face on an everyday basis their. Knights and samurai had many differences and similarities they both came from different countries and they both had different lifesyles if a samurai's dad was a samurai he aslo had to become a samurai, but if a knight's father was a knight it was optional for him to become a knight. Samurai vs knights dbq - free download as pdf file (pdf) or read online for free a dbq that involves the benefits and the differences between samurai and knights and ultimately, which one is better. The samurai look after their swords very well since their swords are their life and honor knights: knights have lots of weapons like: a mace, battle axes, spears and many more knights use any weapons which is good to kill and carry. What was the difference between knights and samurais each was an expression of the culture in which they evolved, and reflect the cultural differences between europe and japan 'samurai' as an institution lasted roughly 1200 years and there were many changes during that time.
Teacher assigned on tuesday feb 26 a 5-paragraph, mla format-based essay that should answer the question: samurai and knights: are the similarities greater than the differences. Samurai and knights: were the similarities greater than the differences should we celebrate the voyages of zheng he the aztecs: should historians emphasize agriculture or human sacrifice. The social position of both samurais and knights was one area with defined similarities samurai and knights had particular codes of honor to follow a samurai was a warrior, but a knight was not only a warrior, but a gentleman as well.
The knights of europe though, wore a lot of armor, and eventually they wore an entire 'metal' suit, which gave them a lot of trouble in movement, and was much heavier than what the samurai wore-plus, it must have literally killed some of them during the summer due to so much heat after all, the medieval knight wore a lot of clothing, as. Samurai and knights essaysthe medieval era saw the emergence of two distinct warrior classes in europe and japan these were the samurai's and the knights they were marked in history as a code for courage and sacrifice. Samurai were expected to live according to bushido, a strict ethical code influenced by confucianism that stressed loyalty to one's master, respect for one's superior, ethical behavior in all aspects of life, and complete self-discipline.